Ingmar Schumacher:

Today, at my favorite environmental economics blog (oh yes it is…), I saw a picture of a robin’s nest. My guess is that the proud photographer didn’t really put the picture there because it is his best wildlife shot ever (sorry, John…), but because he genuinely cares about those birds that are hatching in his garden. However, my guess also is that John, at the same time, is not a vegetarian (right or wrong, John?). How are these two positions reconcilable?

via ingmarschumacher.wordpress.com

Because people don't eat robins? On the other hand, I like cute little baby pigs too and I had bacon this morning. Some things are just unreconcilable.

Posted in ,
  1. Paul Chambers Avatar

    Speciesism: we are biased toward our own species (for example, see the work of Peter Singer). Disclaimer: I’m mainly familiar with Singer’s work via the essay, “The Drowning Child and the Expanding Circle.” Also, genetic distance may matter. Although bushmeat (chimpanzee meat) is consumed by some, many of us will shudder at the thought of consuming chimp meat. Genetic distance isn’t a factor with the robins.
    On the conservation side (and the willingness to pay literature), there is a greater propensity to allocate resources to protect charismatic macrofauna (the large & cute animals).
    I have no grand conclusion besides: humans are funny animals.

  2. D Avatar

    Nah, John’s gonna raise the robins till they’re nice and fat and then eat them!

  3. Ingmarschumacher.wordpress.com Avatar

    So here is a related question: Imagine you ask someone for the WTP for a chicken. And then you ask for the WTA the chicken’s death? Is it going to be the same and if not then for what reasons?
    Or slightly differently: If you see a chicken in a farm and the farmer asks whether you want to eat it, that particular one, would you feel the same about is as if you had bought any particular chicken in a supermarket?
    I really think the processing part does play a role, the personification or the relationship that one has with the animal. And in the moment one has spent some time with an animal, even a short period, that might already be enough to form a sort of bond.

  4. Paul Chambers Avatar

    I like the social distance insights. It also brings to mind,the Portlania short, “Is the chicken local?”

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Environmental Economics

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading